These are pretty reasonable prices. In the five plus years I have owned my Element I have made a lot of trips to the you pull junk yard and every single Element that I have seen there (and there have been a lot of them) have all had both tail lights still on the car. No one comes for them.
Side steps, roof racks, rear spoilers are always gone. Sometimes throttle bodies, accessories like mud flaps or hood deflectors will be gone but tail lamps are always there.